From Gene Hoffman, talking about the New York nunchucks case brought by some idiot who represented himself.
This case is bad news and the pro-se appelant is going to keep going. He’s completely screwed up the 2nd Circuit. However, it is very unlikely to hurt Nordyke. I also agree … that this likely widens the circuit split meaning that the odds of Nordyke or Chicago going to SCOTUS is higher.
The cost is that New York is hosed. This is why you hear us repeat again and again that one shouldn’t bring 2A cases without using one of the right lawyers…
–Gene Hoffman, Chair of the Calguns Foundation, in this post
The case, which really shouldn’t have had anything to do with the Second Amendment at all, has unfortunately now been taken up by Kirkland and Ellis. If we’re lucky, the Supreme Court will ignore the appeal in favor of a more well-crafted case like Nordyke. Middle ground would be if the Court considered both this piece of dreck and Nordyke to resolve the split between the circuits. Worst case, of course, is that this case gets heard all by its lonesome first and we get a really nasty 5-4 decision that starts with nunchaku and lists a whole bunch of stuff that isn’t protected under the 2nd. Which would give us toothless incorporation.
Thanks a lot, Maloney, you jerk.

